Checking Claims in an AI Draft: Materials, Sizes, Origin, Care
Not every sentence in a draft carries the same risk. A line about "a warm, welcoming feel" is opinion. A line about what the item is made of is a fact, and a fact can be wrong.
Chatbots can put plausible-sounding random falsehoods into their writing1. So the job is to find the sentences that state facts and check those first.
The four groups to check hardest
Materials. Fibres, metals, woods, finishes, ingredients. Compare the exact wording with your supplier's sheet. Watch for upgrades: "leather" for "faux leather", "solid" for "veneer", "natural" for something processed.
Sizes and quantities. Every number and unit. Tools mix up centimetres and inches, and they round. Check weight, capacity, pack counts and what's in the box. Put the unit in the sentence.
Origin. Where it was made or grown. Covered in its own section below, because the wording has legal weight.
Care. Washing, cleaning and storage steps. A wrong care line can damage the item and annoy the buyer. Copy care text from the label or the maker's page, not from the draft.
Other statements that slip in
Tools often add things you never gave them. Look for these too:
- Features borrowed from similar products.
- Uses the product wasn't designed for.
- Comparisons ("lighter than most").
- Delivery, stock or return promises.
- Words that imply a certificate or test result.
The ACCC lists false claims about "the quality, style, model or history of a product or service" as something to avoid2. It also says any statement that creates a false impression about goods and services can be breaking the law2. That covers sentences you didn't write yourself.
Origin wording
Origin claims aren't limited to the words "made in". The ACCC says a claim can be implied by words, images or symbols that suggest a product is from a particular country3. An AI draft might add a flag emoji, a phrase like "crafted in the heart of Tuscany", or a map image.
In Australia, the ACCC describes "made in" as generally meaning the last substantial step in the making of the product happened in that country3. Even a correct claim can break the law if extra words or images create an overall misleading impression3. Other countries use different tests, so check your own regulator, for example the FTC in the US. This page is general information, not legal advice.
If your supplier hasn't confirmed where the item was made, leave origin out.
Fast pass versus full pass
| Quick pass | Full pass | |
|---|---|---|
| What you do | Check only the four groups above | Check every sentence against the fact sheet |
| Time | Short | Longer |
| Misses | Borrowed features, delivery promises | Very little |
| Suits | Repeat products with a settled sheet | New products, or any item with a claim about safety, health or the environment |
The ACCC suggests businesses check that the overall general impression is accurate2. Finish with one slow read of the finished page, as a buyer would. Does it leave an impression the product can't live up to? If so, cut.
For health, safety and eco wording, see [page:avoiding-risky-claims-in-product-copy]. To build the sheet you're checking against, see [page:product-fact-sheet-template].
Cited material
- Hallucination (artificial intelligence), Wikipedia
- False or misleading claims, Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC)
- Country of origin claims, Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC)